Some people interested in selling their home have had difficulty doing so, not because they haven't been able to find a buyer, but because the bank's appraiser says the home isn't worth what the home was selling for.
A number of recent reports have highlighted the difficulty many buyers and sellers are having with appraisals in the current real estate market.
With foreclosures being a major factor in some areas, along with lower home prices, appraisers are sometimes coming up with values lower than the selling price. In those cases, either the buyer has to put more money down, or the seller has to drop their price. If neither side is willing to budge, then they either need to find another appraiser or forget the deal completely.
The issue is causing major issues in some markets. Earlier this month, real estate agents in Detroit told the Free Press that appraisals might be derailing up to 40 percent of their sales.
We'd love to know if you've run into a problem with an appraisal affecting a sale you're involved with, either as a buyer, a seller, or even an agent? Use the comment link below to tell us your experience.
Lower Home Appraisals Will Help Some, Hurt Others
Those who get hurt by lower appraisals are the sellers, who become underwater or even more than 25% underwater, which appears to be the threshold for mortgage mitigation programs. The lower the appraised value, the less likely a servicer will be willing to offer a Short Sale and the more likely that the homeowner will default and then foreclose. This could propagate into even lower home prices, exacerbating the problems in the housing market.
This will also hurt the homebuilders because new homes may become unprofitable to build and sell given the higher costs of building materials. In a market where new homes are being sold, the same model can be appraised at a lower price due to defaults up the block from the builder’s site.
This will likely lead to 3.5 to 4.0 million foreclosures this year, up from 2.8 million in 2009. Also keep in mind that the Case Shiller Housing Market Index is 50% higher than in 2000, so home prices have room for another leg down.
We will continue to monitor things and report here from time to time on the state of the housing markets.
Selling a Home? Get an Accurate Appraisal First
In an effort to save a few dollars in this down economy, many would-be-sellers today are turning to computer generated reports to establish the value of their property, rather than paying for a full appraisal. These sites use data that is collated from various resources to come up with estimates of what a property is worth.
Although a professional appraiser is more expensive, they are highly trained to accurately determine the value of many different types of properties, as well as account for many variables the computerized reports don't take into consideration, like surrounding neighborhoods, economic development in the area, and the quality of the school system, just to name a few.
Many lenders don't even require an in-depth inspection or interior inspection of a home, which begs the question: How can a realistic property valuation be arrived at without an on-site inspection? The answer is, it can't.
To obtain state licensing or certification, appraisers must undergo a stringent course of training through an accredited educational facility. In addition, some states require appraisers to complete an apprenticeship with a more seasoned professional before they can operate independently. The best appraisers will consider every aspect of the property, including square footage, room count, types of rooms, condition of property, lot size, neighborhood trends and comparable properties in the area that recently sold, as well as similar properties that are currently on the market.
Locating a qualified appraiser in your area is not a difficult task. Banks and lenders in your neighborhood can often refer you to reputable appraisers.


Home prices rising means good news for the economy, or so everyone thinks.
Article Comments